Where do you draw the line between calling something a muffin and calling it a cupcake? My Favorite Muffin dances around that line at their Centerville, Ohio store. They have tons of custom-built muffins along with bagels that come with creme cheese or a sandwich. A cafe and breakfast menu complete this store.
As you can see here there is a muffin for everyone. You have chocolate muffins, Oreo muffins, cheesecake muffins, cherry muffins, coffeecake muffins, lemon poppy, sugar cookie muffins, and on my visit they even had a Twinkie muffin. You can see their complete menu here. The muffins themselves are huge and delicious, but if want something smaller they have muffin bites pictured above for a bit less.
I ordered a BLT for my breakfast and it was delicious. I loved how they added creme cheese to go along with the bacon, lettuce, and tomato. I had this one on an Asiago cheese bagel. It was fantastic.
Of course I had to get some muffins to go as well. My family was in Ohio for 3 days, and that is how long it took us to finish these off. They were just as delicious on 3rd day as they were on the first day. Above the flavors clockwise starting in the bottom left corner were: lemon poppy-seed, cherry cheesecake, double chocolate, Twinkie, cinnamon, and sugar cookie.
This Twinkie muffin was my favorite. It was filled with thick gooey marshmallow creme! Absolutely loved it!
Another great thing about My Favorite Muffin was the service. The staff there is so friendly. They engaged us in conversation and were great to work with. Even though the restaurant was busy, we didn’t have to wait at all for our service, and the food came out super fast.
Forget donuts! Forget cupcakes! Bring on the muffins!